Blog

Are you looking for a reliable GPS dog tracker but unsure whether to go with Fi, Tractive, or Aorkuler? This in-depth comparison will help you understand the differences and choose the best dog-tracking device for your needs—especially if you enjoy off-grid adventures with your pup.

Basic Information

Tractive GPS dog tracker needs no introduction; if you are looking for pet-related content, it will always jump out at you, whether it's Google, Bing, Amazon, etc... Tractive has a strong market presence and extensive advertising exposure across major platforms.

Fi is an innovative dog tracker brand that launched its Fi3 in October '22, which could be a strategic product for Fi, which has invested a lot of resources around the new product launch and release. The major mainstream and authoritative media outlets also gave it exceptionally high marks.

The Fi3 GPS dog tracker is an innovative tracker product in terms of product and business model. The communication part of the product uses LTE-M. This technology still relies on cellular networks but has lower power consumption compared to 4G or LTE, which can effectively improve battery life. This is why Fi3 dares to claim that its standby time can reach 3 months.

In addition, at the product level, alloy materials, thinner and stronger, better water resistance, etc., are all laudable innovations. In any case, Fi3's product definition is far better than that of brands that rely on their market share and gluttonize commissions from users' subscription fees.

Fi3 also stands out for its innovative business model; after all, selling hardware and paying a monthly subscription fee, although used by big brands, still makes some users feel dissatisfied. Fi cleverly converts subscription fees into membership fees, which lowers the threshold for new users to use for the first time and binds the old users more tightly through upgrades, etc. We appreciate Fi's product and business model.

We appreciate Fi3's innovation in product and business models. Of course, no matter what, solving the customer's problem and getting the user's approval and favorite are everything.

What are the differences between Fi3 and Tractive, and Fi3 and Aorkuler?

📶 Cellular vs Off-Grid Dog Trackers: Fi, Tractive, or Aorkuler?

Fi is cellular-based, so it still requires the cellular network to work. Aorkuler is not, so it doesn't rely on any cellular signal;

Fi3 is based on LTE-M, and under the same environment, it theoretically has a longer cellular coverage distance and lower power consumption than Tractive using LTE; it is more suitable for pet tracking scenarios than Tractive.

Can Tractive GPS Tracker Track Dogs In Rural Areas In Real Time?

💰 GPS Dog Trackers with No Subscription: Which Brand Wins?

Fi also charges a time-based fee, called a membership fee, which covers all the comprehensive costs, including hardware, software, data traffic, services, etc., while Tractive is the standard form of purchasing the hardware separately + paying the subscription fee. In addition, Fi's membership fee cycle is slightly more flexible than Tractive's.

Aorkuler GPS dog tracker does not require a subscription or membership fee. Purchasing the product is the full cost, not hardware rental.

🔧 Design & Hardware

Fi has advantages over Aorkuler and Tractive GPS dog trackers regarding product hardware design, such as architecture, better sealing, and more compact and integrated design. The Tractive is more ordinary;

The Aorkuler dog GPS tracker without subscription is more unique, with a separate controller/Remoter that displays by distance and direction.

📱 App & User Experience

Fi and Tractive both have APP; you can set up some extra functions, such as virtual fence, etc.; however, Fi and Tractive both need to use the cell phone as the input and output interface to work; no cell phone/cell phone without power / Bluetooth off / no signal from cell phone, etc., Fi and Tractive can't be used, Aorkuler functions independently of these limitations.

Aorkuler off-grid GPS dog tracker doesn't matter; it doesn't matter if there is a cell signal or not, if there is a cell phone or not, or if the cell phone has no battery; it doesn't matter if the cell phone has no signal or no battery. However, Aorkuler does not have an APP, so it cannot provide some auxiliary functions.

✅ Use Case Scenarios

• City & Suburbs with Reliable Signal: Fi or Tractive GPS dog tracker works well.
• Remote Hiking / Camping / Travel to Rural Areas: Aorkuler GPS dog tracker with no cell signal is the most reliable.
• Users Who Want No Subscription Fees: Aorkuler GPS dog tracker without a subscription is ideal.
• Tech-Savvy Users Who Want App Features: Fi or Tractive GPS dog tracker may be preferable.

Real User Reviews With The Aorkuler Pet Tracker On Amazon

Other Info

It's important to note that the Fi3 has since been canceled on Amazon; it's impossible to pinpoint the exact reason. However, as you can see from the linked history of reviews, user feedback hasn't been too favorable, with an overall rating of 2.7 out of 5.

The main feedback from customers centers on the following comments:

• Inaccurate GPS positioning with significant delays and errors
• The collar is not the correct size;
• Customer service is not good enough;
• Unavailability in rural or remote areas;

🐶📡 Looking for an off-grid GPS dog tracker that works even when your phone doesn't?

Discover why thousands of outdoor dog owners trust Aorkuler for off-grid reliability—no cell signal, no subscription, no worries.

👉 [Learn more or shop now]